Prohibitive Costs of Medical School and Incurred Debt
Medical School Costs
Student debt is a concern in the US overall, with college costs increasing at a higher rate than inflation for decades now. The rateof tuition increase for medical schools has exceeded other areas of graduate education. Student loan indebtedness has risen right along with college costs,with the median debt at $170,000 for medical school graduates in 2012,according to the Association of American Medical Colleges. They report that nearly 90% of medical students graduate in debt.
Medical School Tuition: Then and Now
- In the late 50s, Warren Widmann earned his first-year tuition for the School of Medicine at Yale, “by waiting tables at a hotel…and...had money left over.” He recalled the costs being “either $650 or $850 a year.”
- In the 70s, medical student Mark's father emigrated from China and graduated debt-free from medical school as an ER physician. Mark's father paid about $3000 per year in the mid-70s (about $13,500 per year in 2014 dollars). In 2012, the cost had risen to almost $50,000 annually, as Bloomberg has reported.
- Today, Mark is in his third year, with a current debt of nearly $200,000. In today's world, even Ben Bernanke's son will graduate with $400,000 in debt from Cornell, according to a statement he made in the House of Representatives.
Challenges That Compound Medical School Debt
Besides dedicating many years of your life to study and delaying your entry into the full-time, fully paid workforce,there are additional sacrifices when you choose a medical career. Spending and/or borrowing money for tuition and living expenses (through medical school and residency) creates significant stress and anxiety about the future. And there are even more costs as you begin your career. You'll likely be payingback student loans while also dealing with costs for licensure, sky-high malpractice insurance premiums, and more. You may even be setting up your own practice with all the overhead costs entailed, including medical and office staff, office space, and more.
What's more, because the Affordable Care Act is still in flux, it's impossible to predict what the health insurance landscape for your future patients will become by the time you graduate. Any changes that will be made to it (and the effects of those changes) are not yet clear. All these obstacles and uncertainties can cause a college student to reconsider his or her chosen career entirely, or to at least choose one of the higher-paying specialties.
Major Effects of Incurred Debt on the Medical Profession
Shortage of primary care physicians: Many medical students choose their specialty based, in part, on the cost of schooling and specialty training. They also look at what they might be paid after they graduate. High costs and relatively low pay have resulted in fewer students choosing family medicine. In just 10 years, the UScould have a deficit of about 50,000 primary care doctors, according to the American Academy of Family Physicians.
Job dissatisfaction: CBS News'Money Watch recently reported that primary care physicians (pediatricians and family and internal medicine physicians) canexpect to earn little more annually than the amount of their medical school debt, based on an analysis of data from the Association of American Medical Colleges, George Washington University,and Medscape by Nerd Wallet. They also reported that internal medicine physicians are the least happy with their career choice.This is attributed to relatively long hours and low salary, combined with limited time with patients and excessive paperwork, none of which make iteasier to repay student loans with payments of $1000 to $3000 monthly.
Which Medical Specialists Are Best Paid and Most Satisfied?
According to the Nerd Wallet analysis, the most highly paid doctors are orthopedic surgeons, who take home an average of $405,000 per year. Cardiologists reported an average salary of $357,000 annually while working the longest hours,at 60 per week. Neurologists reported earning an average of $216,000 and working about 55 hours weekly, with good job satisfaction. More than half (60%) would choose the same specialty. Oncologists were also generally satisfied with their specialty, with about 60% who say they would choose oncology if they could do it all over again.
Solving the Dilemma of Medical School Debt
In an intriguing New York Times Op-Ed column from 2011, Drs. Peter Bach and Robert Kocher proposed making medical school free in order to solve the 2 big,looming problems: the shortage of primary care physicians and outrageous medical school debt. They recommend free medical education by completely funding medical school for all med students by charging physicians for specialty training.
Dean Robert Alpern of Yale University stated that tuition costs cannot be expected to decrease anytime soon, so more endowments are needed to help students bear the costs. The dean stated that he would like to have a tuition-free medical school, but that such an accomplishment would be difficult to achieve.
Practical Solutions: What You Can Do Now to Afford Medical School
Pay off loans with service: Get full or partial college loan debt forgiveness by agreeing to work in under served or rural areas for a few years through the National Health Service Corps Scholars Program. In other loan repayment programs, you agree to work in primary care or earn debt forgiveness through research work. State universities may have similar programs.
Go abroad: Go to a quality medical school in the Bahamas or elsewhere. Some foreign schools qualify for federal loans and may offer accelerated programs. Check to be sure they have a high pass rate for the USMLE. Remember that travel back and forth to see relatives, and your living expenses, must be factored in. Consider also that when you return, you may need an ECFMG certification, must pass the USMLE, and need to compete for US medical residencies.
Move to another state for medical school: If you live in a state with a good program (or are open to relocating), you can get a good deal on your education for your chosen medical degree if you're accepted. To become a resident, you have to live in the state for at least a year or more (varies by state). The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill was rated #2 in the nation by U.S. News' Best Grad Schools for primary care medicine. It has a comparably low tuition of about $17,500 (state residents), although it's $44,500 fo rout-of-state students. That doesn't seem like such a bargain considering that annual tuition is a mere $8300 at the University of Massachusetts (approximately,for in-state students only), ranked #5 for primary care. For U Mass,however, you must have lived in the state for 5 years and/or attended high school there.
Join the military: Tuition is free at the F. Edward Hébert School of Medicine at the Uniformed Services University in Bethesda, MD. One of the caveats, of course:you must commit to service in the military.
Join the Peace Corps: Former med students with loan debt can be awarded funds to reduce their debt or have part of their debt cancelled in exchange for Peace Corps volunteer services. A new travel fellowship, a type of “Peace Corps for doctors,” that pays off school loans at about $30,000 per year of service (for qualified individuals) was recently created by Dr. Vanessa Kerry of Massachusetts General Hospital's Center for Global Health.
- Association of American Medical Colleges.Physician education debt and the cost to attend medical school: 2012 update. Associationof American Medical Colleges website. February 2013. https://www.aamc.org/download/328322/data/statedebtreport.pdf.
- Bach PB, Kocher R. Why medicalschool should be free. New York Times website.May 28, 2011. http://www.med.und.edu/enews/documents/document201106021001433.pdf.
- Best medical schools:primary care. U.S. News website. http://grad-schools.usnews.rankingsandreviews.com/best-graduate-schools/top-medical-schools/primary-care-rankings.
- CollinsS. The high cost of a medical education. Yale Medicine website. http://yalemedicine.yale.edu/spring2011/features/feature/109072.
- Doucleff M. A Peace Corpsfor doctors, built by a senator's daughter. NPR website. September 26, 2012. http://www.npr.org/blogs/health/2012/09/18/161381770/a-peace-corps-for-doctors-built-by-a-senators-daughter.
- Instructions for student loans. Peace Corpswebsite. Updated January 30, 2014. http://www.peacecorps.gov/volunteer/learn/whyvol/finben/instructions.
- Lorin J. Medical school at $278,000 meanseven Bernanke son has debt. Bloomberg website. April 11, 2013. http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-04-11/medical-school-at-278-000-means-even-bernanke-son-carries-debt.html.
- Miles D. Uniformed ServicesUniversity ranks among top medical schools. U.S. Department of Defense website.March 21, 2013. http://www.defense.gov/news/newsarticle.aspx?id=119596.
- Monetary policy and the state of theeconomy. Hearing before the Committee on Financial Services, U.S. House ofRepresentatives. February 29, 2012. Serial No. 112–103. http://financialservices.house.gov/uploadedfiles/112-103.pdf.
- National Health ServiceCorps. Scholarship program overview. National Health Service Corps website. https://nhsc.hrsa.gov/scholarships/overview/.
- Pratini N. Primary careshortage worsens with Obamacare as medical students specialize. NerdWalletwebsite. January 17, 2014. http://www.nerdwallet.com/blog/health/2014/01/17/primary-care-shortage-obamacare-physician-salary-specialty/.